An Honest Guide to the Benefits and Drawbacks of Skylights

Add to
Like
Comment
Share
By Kate Reggev
A skylight might seem like a universally bright idea, but though it can be a great design feature, it isn’t without flaws of its own.

There’s no question about it: skylights are seen as being beneficial to any home because of their ability to bring in natural light. But you may not realize that they can have some serious negative impacts on a space or a whole building for a variety of reasons. 

Benefit #1: Extra Daylight

One of the most positive aspects of having a skylight is that it brings extra daylight into a room, particularly during the winter months when days are shorter, there are fewer hours of sunlight, and the sun is at a lower angle than during the summer. 

An Honest Guide to the Benefits and Drawbacks of Skylights - Photo 1 of 9 - The abstract geometry of this space led to the creation of unusually shaped skylights that were designed to bring in consistent, soft northern light.

The abstract geometry of this space led to the creation of unusually shaped skylights that were designed to bring in consistent, soft northern light.


Benefit #2: Energy Savings

Because of this increase in natural light from skylights, the use of artificial lighting and electricity can be reduced, and during the colder months, skylights can contribute to the heat gain of a space and reduce the need for heating. Aside from the positive environmental impact that comes with using less electricity, the use of skylights has the potential to even reduce electric bills. 

An Honest Guide to the Benefits and Drawbacks of Skylights - Photo 2 of 9 - A paneled wood ceiling is kept bright and airy because of three large skylights.

A paneled wood ceiling is kept bright and airy because of three large skylights.


Benefit #3: Design Options

Another asset of skylights is their flexibility and range of design options, which can vary in location, size, shape, and angle so that they take advantage of local conditions. A skylight can be designed to capture early morning sunlight to help heat a space, but also so that it misses the strong afternoon sun that might make a room too warm. Some skylights come with shades or coatings to prevent overheating. 

An Honest Guide to the Benefits and Drawbacks of Skylights - Photo 3 of 9 - With no windows on the walls of this bedroom, natural light enters through a skylight on the gabled roof.

With no windows on the walls of this bedroom, natural light enters through a skylight on the gabled roof.


Benefit #4: Design Impact

Finally, skylights have the potential to either dramatically enhance a design or act as the main design feature in a space. Traditionally, they've been placed in spaces that were otherwise unable to have access to natural light through traditional windows, like the top of a staircase. However, they can also have the bonus effect of creating dramatic lighting and a sense of upward ascension that can still inspire designers today. 

An Honest Guide to the Benefits and Drawbacks of Skylights - Photo 4 of 9 - This living room is further lit by three protruding skylights that are angled to catch morning and afternoon light.

This living room is further lit by three protruding skylights that are angled to catch morning and afternoon light.


Drawback #1: Overheating and Over-Lighting

Though this abundance of rays can be a lifesaver in some spaces, it can also lead to potential problems related to bringing too much light and heat into your space. Make sure you keep this in mind when it comes time to decide on placement, size, direction, climate control, and how you'll be using the space.

An Honest Guide to the Benefits and Drawbacks of Skylights - Photo 5 of 9 - A small circular skylight serves as a vertical focal point in the center of this stairwell, and provides much-needed natural light. The white walls of the stairs bounce light, but the darker wood treatment ensures that the space is not too bright.

A small circular skylight serves as a vertical focal point in the center of this stairwell, and provides much-needed natural light. The white walls of the stairs bounce light, but the darker wood treatment ensures that the space is not too bright.


Drawback #2: Heat Loss

Another issue with skylights is that they often lose heat during cool months. As a general rule, glass conducts heat better than other building materials like insulation or concrete, allowing heat from inside a home to escape to the outside. To combat this, homeowners should choose skylights that are thermally-broken (meaning that no piece of hardware or trim directly connects the outside to the inside), and that the glass is insulated. 

An Honest Guide to the Benefits and Drawbacks of Skylights - Photo 6 of 9 - Triple-glazed windows were used in this home in Canada to try and mitigate heat loss through the skylights.

Triple-glazed windows were used in this home in Canada to try and mitigate heat loss through the skylights.


Drawback #3: Installation Issues

Even if a skylight is insulated, there are frequently problems with sealing the shaft properly and making sure that it’s properly installed. All too often, a skylight isn’t correctly installed, leading to moisture problems and leaks that can not only drip into spaces below, but also spread leaks to other parts of the roof that were previously dry. What might have seemed like a minor leak could eventually lead to a much larger, complex issue. 

An Honest Guide to the Benefits and Drawbacks of Skylights - Photo 7 of 9 - Skylights must be properly installed and sealed to prevent leaks and other issues.

Skylights must be properly installed and sealed to prevent leaks and other issues.


Drawback #4: Cleaning Troubles

Finally, skylights can be tricky to clean. If you’re in the habit of spring cleaning and like to embark on the annual ritual of washing all your windows, you’ll probably find cleaning your skylights to be difficult, if not downright unsafe. To reduce the number of regular cleanings, you’ll want to make sure that they’re installed in areas where they aren’t likely to have leaves or branches falling on them, which would require frequent clearing or cleaning. 

An Honest Guide to the Benefits and Drawbacks of Skylights - Photo 8 of 9 - A dining room and kitchen benefit from the pale blue light that comes in through a skylight at dusk.

A dining room and kitchen benefit from the pale blue light that comes in through a skylight at dusk.


An Honest Guide to the Benefits and Drawbacks of Skylights - Photo 9 of 9 - Skylights are visible—and easily reached for cleaning—from this rooftop terrace in New York.

Skylights are visible—and easily reached for cleaning—from this rooftop terrace in New York.

At the end of the day, a skylight—despite its flaws—can be a powerful design element and an important tool for incorporating daylight into a space. That is, so long as they're in a well-considered spot, have proper glazing, and have been installed correctly.

Get a Daily Dose of Design

Sign up for the Dwell Daily Newsletter and never miss our new features, photos, home tours, stories, and more.