Before & After: Siblings Turn a Neglected Victorian Into a Dreamy Catskills Hotel

"How I judge a bar, restaurant, or hotel is the bathroom," says Leah, who chose bold Mulberry wallpaper and Huey sconces for the facilities on the ground floor. The sinks came from a pile discovered on the property. "The previous owner’s late husband was into collecting old fixtures," she says. "They were buried under mud and leaves, and [the manager] Chris scrubbed those for probably eight hours each."