Big Spoon Roasters Handcrafted Nut Butter, Set of 2

Nuts, nuts everywhere.

PB&Js are getting a major revamp: These nut butters come straight from North Carolina, where they’re made to order with top-notch ingredients (we’re talking fresh-roasted peanuts, almonds, and cashews, along with raw wildflower honey and hand-harvested sea salt). Oh, and fun fact—they’re totally free of gluten, soy, and palm oil, to boot. There’s nutty blends of all kinds here, with flavor combos like chai spice, chocolate-espresso, and ginger-coconut. Whatever you snag, you’ll be getting two 13-ounce jars of made-from-scratch goodness.