written by:
photos by:
August 26, 2014
Originally published in Modern Dreams
as
The Art of Compromise
Inspired by their clients’ bold art collection, a pair of architects designs a Hamptons vacation house that subverts tradition.
Hamptons modern pool off gabled house with cedar paneling

Even the pool is the result of mixed influences: Andrew wanted a series of shallow, gently sloping hangout zones; his wife, Amy, a former competitive swimmer, needed a full lane deep enough for laps.

Photo by 
1 / 12
Hamptons living room with towering head sculpture and metallic fireplace

Andrew Weinstein stands in the living room of his Long Island abode designed by Bates Masi + Architects. The architects toggled wall panels and panes of custom-cut window glass on the front of the house that let in light while leaving room for large-format artwork like Adam Parker Smith’s American Totem.

Photo by 
2 / 12
Dining room with white lacquer table, Cherner chairs, and a large artwork

A white lacquer Ligne Roset dining table is joined by a wood bench from Room & Board and bent-plywood Cherner chairs. Baconcube 4 by Cindy Wright hangs on the wall.

Photo by 
3 / 12
Hamptons house exterior with precast concrete panels with wood framing

The gabled house, constructed from precast concrete panels by Superior Walls with wood framing, offers a pared-down suggestion of a traditional New England silhouette. The exterior cedar paneling also appears on the ceiling of the custom-built chef’s kitchen inside.

Photo by 
4 / 12
Kitchen with white marble countertops and white fiberboard cabinetry

Bates Masi designed the two-inch-thick Carrara marble countertops and white fiberboard cabinetry in the kitchen.

Photo by 
5 / 12
White stairwell with Jacqueline Kennedy artwork and skylight

In the stairwell hangs a series of 1999 Vik Muniz works that resemble Andy Warhol’s iconic portraits of Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis, but are actually photographs of pooled ketchup.

 

Photo by 
6 / 12
Living too with fallen wood table and Hans Wegner chair

Interior designer Danielle Roberts sought practical materials for the living room, such as custom wide-wale upholstery for a CB2 sofa. The fallen-wood coffee table is by St. Louis–based designer David Stine; the chair is by Hans Wegner for Carl Hansen & Søn.

Photo by 
7 / 12
Hamptons bedroom with glass walls and American flag print

The glass-walled master suite opens to the surrounding forest and gardens and feels totally separate from the children’s and guest bedrooms upstairs.

Photo by 
8 / 12
Garage of Hamptons house with wooden horizontal stakes

The first-floor exterior walls and fence are clad with horizontal survey stakes, identical to the ones that dotted the lot when the Weinsteins first bought it; the humble picket shapes pull off a graphic effect when collaged en masse. 

Photo by 
9 / 12
Gabled living room with metallic fireplace

The living room fireplace is tiled with military-issue dog tags.

Photo by 
10 / 12
Modern wooden outdoor shower

A wood-lined outdoor shower adds a modern touch to one of the decks.

Photo by 
11 / 12
Hamptons floor plan

Weinstein Residence Floor Plan

A    Entry

B    Bathroom

C    Dining Area

D    Living Area

E    Kitchen

F    Terrace

G    Office

H    Master Bedroom

I    Master Bathroom

J    Outdoor Shower

K    Bedroom

Photo by 
12 / 12
Hamptons modern pool off gabled house with cedar paneling

Even the pool is the result of mixed influences: Andrew wanted a series of shallow, gently sloping hangout zones; his wife, Amy, a former competitive swimmer, needed a full lane deep enough for laps.

Project 
Weinstein Residence
Interior Designer 

Judging by their art collection, Andrew and Amy Weinstein appear to be unabashed risk-takers. A cartoon phallus, drawn on what looks like a steamed-up mirror, hangs in the bathroom of their Amagansett, New York, vacation home. A 16-foot-tall totem, made of rubber masks and spray foam, holds court in the double-height living room. 

Despite this yen for the subversive in contemporary art, the couple’s architectural choices were, for years, somewhat conventional. When not living in their midcentury co-op on Manhattan’s East Side, the Weinsteins escaped to a shingled 1,050-square-foot cottage on the Atlantic Ocean in Amagansett. When their first child began crawling in 2005, they initially looked into adding a basement playroom and second floor to the house. But when the high water table rendered that impossible—and Amy became pregnant with the couple’s second child—they decided to start over on a roughly two-acre wooded lot a couple of miles inland. The plan was to reinterpret their beloved vintage cottage on a scale large enough to accommodate both their burgeoning family and their art collection—“a house house,” says Amy. “Looking back,” says Andrew, “it was about going with what we knew.” 

Hamptons living room with towering head sculpture and metallic fireplace

Andrew Weinstein stands in the living room of his Long Island abode designed by Bates Masi + Architects. The architects toggled wall panels and panes of custom-cut window glass on the front of the house that let in light while leaving room for large-format artwork like Adam Parker Smith’s American Totem.

But after canvassing the architectural talent on Long Island’s East End—where faux-traditional trophy estates dominate the beachscape—the couple felt uninspired. They finally connected with Paul Masi and Harry Bates of Bates Masi + Architects—in spite of the Sag Harbor firm’s distinctly modern oeuvre. “We were really looking to build a fairly traditional Hamptons cottage,” says Andrew, a criminal defense attorney. “But we fell in love with Paul and Harry as people.” This was, in part, because the architects’ philosophy of design as storytelling reminded the Weinsteins of the artists whose work they collect. “We are drawn to conceptual and process-driven art and less concerned with its ultimate aesthetic,” Andrew adds. “I work in a courtroom with judges and rules, where the thinking can be fairly constricted. Talking and dealing with people who function on a completely different level is a creative outlet for me.” 

The collaboration began as a holistic discussion about how the Weinsteins planned to use the house and how their needs would change as their children, now ten and seven, grew up. “I said, ‘Let’s go into this project not talking about traditional style, but talking about how you live, what inspires you, what you like to do,’” says Masi. The Weinsteins’ desire for relief from their cramped urban life led to an open-plan first floor with a broad deck, floor-to-ceiling sliding doors, and wide expanses of glass uniting inside and out. Their wish to own larger-scale sculptures inspired the double-height ceiling. The front of the living area consists mostly of walls—to optimize art display space—with carefully placed slots of glass to let in light. A glass-walled master suite opens to the surrounding forest and gardens and feels totally separate from the children’s and guest bedrooms upstairs. “The design process was so much more than giving us a set of blueprints,” says Andrew. 

Kitchen with white marble countertops and white fiberboard cabinetry

Bates Masi designed the two-inch-thick Carrara marble countertops and white fiberboard cabinetry in the kitchen.

To integrate traditional and modern elements, the architects took a cue from the Weinsteins’ idiosyncratic art collection, whose recurring theme, if it can be said to have one, is that things are not quite what they seem. “Andrew’s art was unique because it had deeper meaning,” says Masi. “I really liked that multilayered concept.” This line of thought informed what Masi calls the house’s “narrative of discovery” and how the architects repurposed humble and old-fashioned shapes and materials to create something radically different.

From form to finishes, the four-bedroom, 3,400-square-foot house wittily and easily blends old and new. The gabled silhouette, constructed over 18 months using a combination of precast insulated concrete materials and wood framing, offers a
pared-down suggestion of a traditional house while incorporating thoughtful modern details. “When you approach from a distance, you see these very familiar forms,” says Masi. “But as you come closer, you realize that they’re somewhat modified, with material and fabrication details that are unique.” The first-floor exterior walls and fence, for example, are clad with horizontal survey stakes, identical to the ones that dotted the lot when the Weinsteins first bought it; the humble picket shapes pull off a graphic effect when collaged en masse. The chimney appears to be cast from solid concrete but is actually composed of lightweight autoclaved cement panels affixed to a lath system, with screws left exposed. 

Living too with fallen wood table and Hans Wegner chair

Interior designer Danielle Roberts sought practical materials for the living room, such as custom wide-wale upholstery for a CB2 sofa. The fallen-wood coffee table is by St. Louis–based designer David Stine; the chair is by Hans Wegner for Carl Hansen & Søn.

The Weinsteins did get their cherished Hamptons shingles—they lend warmth to the exterior’s upper level—but as the process unfolded, the couple underwent their own transformation, from reluctant modernists to enthusiastic ones. When Masi suggested classic wood-framed doors and windows, the couple instead opted for steel. “There was less and less resistance, and then no resistance, toward anything Paul wanted to do,” says Amy. “By the time we got to the end of the project,” her husband adds, “we were actually pushing them to go more and more modern.”

Join the Discussion

Loading comments...

Latest Articles

in the mix antwerp belgium warehouse renovation live work space lounge area cushions dining table kitchenette borge mogensen cabinets
An artist and an architect build their home, studios, and an exhibition space inside an Antwerp warehouse.
February 13, 2016
senses sight products kinetic wire sculpture alexander calder mobile
A phenomenon of light and visual perception, colors signal a language of their own.
February 13, 2016
beach weathered seaside retreat sagaponack new york pine walls aluminum furniture
Balancing texture, proportion, and found objects lends unexpected sophistication to a seaside retreat.
February 13, 2016
Concrete floor, white walls, Bend sectional sofa, Metropolitan chair by B&B Italia, and Arper pouf in living room of Rhode Island family vacation home by Bernheimer Architecture.
Create comfortable areas to lounge, sit, eat, and entertain with these designs.
February 12, 2016
São Paulo apartment dining room with local wood floors and HAY chairs
From concrete to wood, these South American homes enjoy nature inside and out.
February 12, 2016
Custom cabinetry and trim in Chicago apartment renovation.
The Second City is second to none when it comes to inventive modern architecture, from Louis Sullivan to the present day.
February 12, 2016
Kitchen of 1956 midcentury modern Palm Springs home.
Celebrate Palm Springs Modernism Week, which runs from February 11–21, with a look at some of our favorite modern desert oases.
February 12, 2016
Gustav bicycle by Coh&Co
Designmuseum Danmark unveils a permanent collection highlighting new developments in Danish design.
February 12, 2016
A Seattle studio's courtyard
Every week, we highlight one amazing Dwell home that went viral on Pinterest. Follow Dwell's Pinterest account for more daily design inspiration.
February 12, 2016
Chalet in the French alps
An innovative glass addition adds contrast to a timber mountain lodge in France.
February 11, 2016
Aumas' assorted collectables.
Bright colors and vintage furniture are abound in these French homes.
February 11, 2016
Kogan designed a number of the built-in furnishings, including the headboard and cupboard in the master bedroom.The cupboard is deliberately reminiscent of a mid-century stereo speaker. The vintage lounge chairs are by Percival Lafer.
Need to relax? Make your bedroom an oasis from the rest of the house.
February 11, 2016
Modern Florida seaside home with corian island, dornbracht faucet, cees braakman combex chairs and marble knoll table in the kitchen
Read more about Knoll's impressive career here, but in the meantime, explore just a few of her works in these contemporary homes.
February 11, 2016
Modern small box home in Mexico
Letting the warm climate indoors is a common thread through these diverse dwellings.
February 11, 2016
Modern white cabinets under the stairs with skylight above
What could be better than a modest-sized house in a quaintly historic city?
February 11, 2016
dining room lighting
These renovations connect rustic, classic, and modern design in Italy.
February 10, 2016
12362509 211441865858796 1743381178 n1
Each week, we tap into Dwell's Instagram community to bring you the most viral design and architecture shots of the week.
February 10, 2016
modern outdoor garden room plastic polycarbonate
From colorful living rooms to a backyard retreat, Belgian designers reimagine vernacular forms and materials for the modern world.
February 10, 2016
Tel Aviv kitchen with custom dining table and Smeg fridge
Would you go for an out-of-the-box palette for your major appliances? See how these kitchens tackle the trend.
February 10, 2016
Exhibition view, of Klaus Wittkugel works at P! gallery, New York
On view through February 21 at New York's P! gallery, a new show explores the politics of Cold War-era graphic design with a presentation of works by Klaus Wittkugel—East Germany's most prolific graphic designer. Curator Prem Krishnamurthy walks us through the highlights.
February 10, 2016
Reclaimed cedar and gray-stucco home outside San Francisco.
The new kid on the block in a predominantly Eichler neighborhood, this Menlo Park home breaks the mold and divides into three pavilions connected by breezeways.
February 10, 2016
A third floor addition and whole-house renovation modernized a funky cottage on an unusual, triple-wide lot in San Francisco.
From modern interiors hidden within historic structures to unabashedly modern dwellings, these seven renovations take totally different approaches to San Francisco's historic building stock.
February 10, 2016
Delphi sofa from Erik Jørgensen and gyrofocus fireplace in living room of Villa Le Trident in the French Riviera, renovated by 4a Architekten.
The Aegean's all-white architecture famously helped inspire Le Corbusier; these five dwellings continue in that proud modern tradition (though not all are as minimalist).
February 10, 2016
San Francisco dining room with chandelier and Eames shell chairs
Brooklyn-based RBW's work—from diminutive sconces to large floor lamps—shape these five interiors.
February 09, 2016
Glass-fronted converted garage in Washington
These garages go behind parking cars and storing your drum sets.
February 09, 2016
Modern Texas home office with sliding walls, behr black chalkboard paint, concrete walls, and white oak flooring
From appropriated nooks to glass-encased rooms, each of these modern offices works a unique angle.
February 09, 2016
picnic-style table in renovated San Francisco house
From chandeliers to pendants, these designs make the dining room the most entertaining space in the house.
February 09, 2016
Midcentury house in Portland with iron colored facade and gold front door
From preserved masterworks to carefully updated time capsules, these homes have one thing in common (other than a healthy appreciation for everything Eames): the conviction that the '40s, '50s, and '60s were the most outstanding moments in American architecture.
February 09, 2016
Modern living room with furniture designed by Ludovica + Roberto Palomba
These oases by the sea, many done up in white, make stunning escapes.
February 08, 2016
A Philippe Starck standing lamp and an Eames chaise longue bracket the living room; two Lawrence Weiner prints hang behind a pair of Warren Platner chairs and a table purchased from a River Oaks estate sale; at far left of the room, a partial wall of new
Texas might have a big reputation, but these homes show the variety of shapes and sizes in the Lone Star State.
February 08, 2016