written by:
June 27, 2009

Last night, the Dwell on Design 2009 keynote speaker Daniel Pink serenaded us into cocktail hour with brevity, levity and repetition.

dan pink headshot

Bounding onto the stage with enough energy to max out every solar panel on the trade show floor (and then some) the New York Times bestselling author Daniel Pink warmed up the packed-house crowd with a series of experiments which are like brain teasers for the creative class.

The first, his "candle problem" showed that when a group of people were asked to solve a conceptual problem, they actually did worse when incentives are involved. The second transported us back to 1994, where he pitches the wacky concept of Wikipedia—and it seems pretty crazy when he spells it out like this—and once again, people working for free, no incentives, beat out Microsoft's funded encyclopedia Encarta, which will fold this year. Besides Biological (self-preservation, sexual) and Extrinsic (raises, promotions), we also have Intrinsic motivation: The inherent tendency to seek out novelty and challenges to extend and exercise our capacity to explore and learn.

It turns out rewards and punishments work, but only in a very narrow set of situations. Performance depends not on the Extrinsic pressures (or Biological) it depends on our level of creative engagement. This is most evident inside the organizational structures, which we can look at like operating systems for computers. 1.0 was Biological (motivation of working together to find food, or you'll die), 2.0 was Extrinsic (they typical carrot-and-stick, which worked well for office efficiency). We're still in 2.0 culturally, but it's crashing more than we'd like to admit. The open source technology—good old Wikipedia—proves this. So do freelance-based firms with loose organizational structures. The new word on college campuses from those hiring: "If you need me to motivate you, I probably don't want to hire you." 3.0 is of course Intrinsic. And for creative, right-brained tasks and thinkers, if the motivation isn't Intrinsic, it can actually do damage. Damage!

So what's motivating for us right-brainers in these 2.0 times?

Autonomy: It's our nature to be curious and self-directed. But too many of us become passive and inert. So this means giving people more control over these things—task, technique, time, team—the better you're going to perform.

Mastery: We all like to get better at things. We love to have moments of intense creativity—call it flow. If we don't encourage this in our workgroups we stifle motivation.

Purpose: Knowing that we have something greater that we're working towards. There's only one problem, and Pink used a phrase coined by Chicago designer Jim Coudal to illustrate it: The Tyranny of the Client. Of course, the only way to avoid this is to become the clients. Publish and produce your own products and ideas. What's stopping you? Well, says Coudal: "When you're your own client, who are you going to make fun of after work at the bar?" So the other option is to educate your clients to think more like designers. And this was something that Charles and Ray Eames did elegantly. They would work with constraints, but they would never compromise. At one time, Anheuser-Busch asked them to redesign their logo. The Eames spent months looking it over, but eventually they refused to take the commission, claiming that the existing logo was perfect for the company already. Charles Eames once said that the designer is the host, and the client is the guest. This makes design more like a public service, fulfilling that Purpose that is ultimately the most important part of everything we do. "Eventually everything connects," Eames said.

And that could not be more apparent right now, as we move towards Motivation 3.0.

Join the Discussion

Loading comments...

Latest Articles

senses smell products
The nose knows: Though fleeting and immaterial, scent is the lifeblood of Proustian memories, both evoking and imprinting visceral associations.
February 06, 2016
design icon josef frank villa beer vienna
Josef Frank: Against Design, which runs through April 2016 at Vienna’s Austrian Museum of Applied Arts/Contemporary Art, is a comprehensive study of the prolific architect, designer, and author.
February 06, 2016
senses sound products
From an alarm to a symphony, audio frequencies hold the power to elicit an emotional call-and-response.
February 06, 2016
Italian Apline home with double-height walls on one facade.
Every week, we highlight one amazing Dwell home that went viral on Pinterest. Follow Dwell's Pinterest account for more daily design inspiration.
February 05, 2016
A built-in sofa with Design Tex upholstery marks the boundary between the two-level addition and the bungalow. Leading up to the master bedroom, a perforated metal staircase, lit from above, casts a Sigmar Polke–like shadow grid on the concrete floor.
From a minimalist Walter Gropius design to a curving sculptural stair, these six stairways run the gamut.
February 05, 2016
distant structure lakeside prefab norway facade stones green roof
Dwell has traveled all over the world, from Tasmania to Indonesia, to report on modern houses.
February 05, 2016
modern lycabettus penthouse apartment master bedroom atrium
Get ready for a weekend of rest with these sleepy, little cocoons.
February 05, 2016
lamp show 99 cent plus gallery 0
At Brooklyn's 99¢ Plus gallery, 30 artists and designers re-imagine the lamp in an illuminating light show.
February 04, 2016
Hidden storage stairwell with raw brass hardware
Having ample space to stow items is a daily struggle—peep these modern homes for some ideas on maximizing your square footage.
February 04, 2016
modern fairhaven beach house blackbutt eucalyptus living room Patricia Urquiola sofa
Whether it's along a coast in Australia or the French Alps, wood provides a natural touch in these interiors.
February 04, 2016
Glass and steel sculpture in Printemps store of Paris.
In the Paris' venerable Printemps department store, two Toronto-based firms were tasked with enlivening a new atrium and creating a unique experience for visitors. YabuPushelberg, partnering with UUfie, designed this stunning steel "sail" embedded with vibrant dichroic glass.
February 04, 2016
Monochromatic Master Bedroom in Copenhagen Townhouse
Whether it's to maximize limited light or create a soothing interior, these five projects go white in a big way.
February 04, 2016
EQ3 Assembly quilt by Kenneth LaVallee
The new Assembly collection from EQ3 celebrates up-and-coming figures in Canadian design. Discover this newly appointed class, which debuted at Toronto's Interior Design Show, here.
February 03, 2016
The Greenhouses of Half Moon Bay
Each week, we tap into Dwell's Instagram community to bring you the most viral design and architecture shots of the week.
February 03, 2016
Deck of Australian addition to Edwardian home.
A 1,500-square-foot home in Melbourne welcomes a modern black and white kitchen, dining, and living area.
February 03, 2016
open plan concrete home in japan
Embracing the organic, imperfect material, these raw concrete surfaces are a step up from exposed brick.
February 03, 2016
Renovated DC Row House loft space with Arne Jacobsen Egg Chair.
The classic designer's signature and comfortable forms continue to be popular in homes today.
February 03, 2016
Zinc-roofed cabin France.
An architect builds an energy-efficient home near one of France’s most popular pilgrimage sites.
February 03, 2016
1973 Palm Springs home
Made for casual design enthusiasts and Palm Springs connoisseurs alike, Unseen Midcentury Desert Modern offers a peek into 51 buildings—some not open to the public—in that Southern California mecca of modernism. Begun in 2008 by photographer Dan Chavkin, the book is set for release this February 9th and will be available on Amazon and at multiple venues of Modernism Week in Palm Springs, February 11 - 21. Here we preview some of its images.
February 03, 2016
Millennial concept home with an outdoor living area
A concept home aims to reflect the requests of the Millennial market.
February 03, 2016
The two twelve-by-sixteen-foot bedrooms, directly above a comparable pair on the first floor, feature a glass transom that follows the pitch of the roof. “The stair and railings were very simple,” Depardon observes. “We added a bit of design, with panels
Skylights needn't be simple overhead daylighting; sometimes they can truly define a room.
February 03, 2016
Modern small space Rhode Island cottage with landscaping and cedar cladding
Surrounded by nature, these cottages are tranquil retreats from the city.
February 03, 2016
The couple kept original touches, including the arch.
Historic archways belie these contemporary homes with physical reminders of each structure's storied past.
February 03, 2016
modern guesthouse in norway with angular facade and cutaway patio with spruce cladding and ikea chair
These houses make room for nature, not the other way around.
February 02, 2016
Modern kitchen with yellow sectioned walls and monochrome appliances
Whether it's a splash of color or bold strokes, this collection of interiors brightens up these homes.
February 02, 2016
Rust-washed concrete wall in Moscow apartment renovation.
This 590-square-foot apartment was stripped down to admit sunlight and dramatically reveal forgotten surfaces.
February 02, 2016
Nendo's collection of objects inspired by Star Wars
In a galaxy not so far away, Japanese studio Nendo has released a versatile collection of objects inspired by classic Star Wars characters.
February 02, 2016
Monti catered to his mother’s love of cooking by giving her ample storage areas along the 70-foot long walnut wall-slash-cabinet. The refrigerator, kitchen items and other goods easily disappear into the wall when not in use. The nonporous, stain-, scratc
Sometimes the earthy colors and vivid grain of a wood like walnut is all you need to make a space.
February 02, 2016
renovated modern home in Austin interior kitchen
From California to Connecticut, these midcentury interiors still shine through thanks to the careful attention of architects and residents alike.
February 02, 2016
Outdoor dining area at a Saigon home.
A city home honors the local culture with communal outdoor space and reclaimed materials.
February 02, 2016