A Heavenly Home in a Converted Church Hits the Market for $2.5M

The storied Rifton in upstate New York has lived many lives since it was built in 1876—and now it’s ready for a new chapter.
Text by

Location: 1883 New York 213 Rifton, New York

Price: $2,495,000

Year Built: 1876

Footprint: 6,286 square feet (four bedrooms, three-and-a-half baths)

Lot Size: 0.5 acres

From the Agent: "Introducing The Rifton, a fully restored and masterfully renovated 1876 stone residence perched above the Wallkill River between Kingston and New Paltz, in the hamlet of Rifton, New York. Over the years, The Rifton has served as a church, a town hall, and the bâtiment canards for a local duck farm, and the current incarnation beautifully preserves this spirit of gathering and community throughout all the living, entertaining, and work spaces spanning over 6,000 square feet. Preserving original elements from each of the iterations, The Rifton has been artfully restored with incredible attention to detail and wabi-sabi modernism, resonating throughout the space in the perfectly imperfect details like exposed beams and bedrock ledges, original stone walls and pine floors, and antique doors layered in timeless patina."

Nestled on a forested lot, the property is a serene oasis set two hours north of New York City.

Nestled on a forested lot, the property is a serene oasis set two hours north of New York City.

A Heavenly Home in a Converted Church Hits the Market for $2.5M - Photo 2 of 10 -
Exposed beams pop against the light hardwood floors and neutral walls on the main level.

Exposed beams pop against the light hardwood floors and neutral walls on the main level.

A Heavenly Home in a Converted Church Hits the Market for $2.5M - Photo 4 of 10 -
Lofted above the great room is a vaulted atelier that features a spiral staircase and a material mix of stone, steel, and wood. 

Lofted above the great room is a vaulted atelier that features a spiral staircase and a material mix of stone, steel, and wood. 

A Heavenly Home in a Converted Church Hits the Market for $2.5M - Photo 6 of 10 -
The bathroom in the primary suite features natural bedrock walls and large claw-foot soaking tub is.

The bathroom in the primary suite features natural bedrock walls and large claw-foot soaking tub is.

A Heavenly Home in a Converted Church Hits the Market for $2.5M - Photo 8 of 10 -
A peek at the sprawling entertaining space on the second level. In addition to 30-foot-tall ceilings, there is also a Viking-inspired, custom stone-and-steel firepit.

A peek at the sprawling entertaining space on the second level. In addition to 30-foot-tall ceilings, there is also a Viking-inspired, custom stone-and-steel firepit.

A Heavenly Home in a Converted Church Hits the Market for $2.5M - Photo 10 of 10 -

1883 New York 213 in Rifton, New York, is currently listed for $2,495,000 by Angelica Ferguson and Annabel Taylor of Sotheby's International Realty.

Dwell Staff
Questions? Pitches? Email edit@dwell.com

Published

Get the Real Estate Newsletter

From midcentury classics to the best contemporary spaces for sale, see the latest listings for modern homes on the market around the world.